Choosing a Small Pet

Guinea Pigs vs Hamsters as Pets

Guinea pigs or hamsters? Compare social needs, daily activity, housing space, diet and running costs to see which small pet suits your home and schedule.

On this page
  1. Are hamsters related to guinea pigs?
  2. Quick comparison
  3. Social needs
  4. Handling and temperament
  5. Diet and vitamin C
  6. Housing and space
  7. Noise, schedule and running costs
  8. Which should you choose?

Guinea pigs suit people who want a social, daytime-active pet and can provide more floor space and daily care. Hamsters suit people who want a smaller, solitary pet that is active at night and takes up less room, but they are not low-maintenance. The two cannot share a cage, so you will need to choose one.

Only distantly. Both are rodents, but they belong to different families. Guinea pigs are in the Caviidae family, and hamsters are in the Cricetidae family. Hamsters are more closely related to voles and lemmings than to guinea pigs, and the two lineages split a very long time ago.

Guinea pigs come from the Andes of South America and were domesticated thousands of years ago. Syrian hamsters come from the Middle East and entered laboratories in the 1930s and then the pet trade in the 1940s.

Quick comparison

Guinea pig Syrian hamster Dwarf hamster
Adult weight 700–1,200 g 100–200 g 20–60 g
Typical lifespan 5–8 years 2–3 years 1.5–2.5 years
Social needs Needs a companion Must live alone Usually alone; advice varies
Most active Daytime, with short naps Dusk and night Dusk and night
Sound Squeaks (“wheeks”) and purrs Quiet, but wheel noise at night Quiet, but wheel noise at night
Running cost Higher Lower Lower

Social needs

Guinea pigs are herd animals. They do best with a companion of the same sex, or a neutered male kept with females. Plan for a companion from the start, because a single guinea pig can become stressed and lonely.

Syrian hamsters must live alone. Housing two together usually leads to fighting. Dwarf hamsters are less predictable, and pairs often fight, so most owners keep them alone. Advice on this varies, so check with a vet or an experienced rodent keeper.

Can I leave my guinea pig alone for 2 days?

Two days alone is risky for a guinea pig. Guinea pigs need fresh vegetables, fresh water and hay every day, and illness can go unnoticed. If you have to travel, arrange someone to visit every day to feed, check water and watch for signs of illness. Your guinea pig should already have a companion.

Handling and temperament

Guinea pigs rarely bite. Many enjoy being held once they are comfortable with you, though some stay shy. They are prey animals, so they startle easily and do best with calm, low-stress handling.

Hamsters are small and fast. They are solitary and territorial, and they are more likely to nip if they are startled or woken during the day.

Which is the friendliest small pet?

No single pet is friendliest. Guinea pigs are often described as gentle and social, and they rarely bite. Hamsters are less interactive, which suits people who prefer watching. If you want a more interactive rodent, rats are another option; see rats vs guinea pigs as pets.

Do hamsters like to be held?

Some hamsters tolerate handling once they are tame, but many do not enjoy being held for long. Let a hamster wake on its own before you handle it, and scoop it up gently from below. A startled hamster is more likely to bite.

Diet and vitamin C

Guinea pigs are herbivores. They need unlimited grass hay, a daily amount of fresh vegetables, and a source of vitamin C, usually a vitamin C-fortified guinea pig pellet plus fresh vegetables. Guinea pigs cannot make their own vitamin C, so it has to come from food every day.

Hamsters are omnivores. They do well on a seed mix or lab block, some fresh vegetables, and a little protein. They make their own vitamin C. For both species, keep sugary treats to a minimum.

Housing and space

Guinea pigs need floor space more than height. Two guinea pigs need at least 0.7 m² (about 7.5 sq ft), and 1 m² (about 10.5 sq ft) or more is better. A single-level enclosure works well. Avoid ramps and climbing structures, and do not use wheels or exercise balls.

Hamsters need a floor area of about 100 × 50 cm (about 39 × 20 in) or more, and 15 to 20 cm (6 to 8 in) of bedding so they can burrow. Give a solid-surface wheel: about 28 cm (11 in) or wider for Syrians and about 20 cm (8 in) or wider for dwarfs. Avoid wire floors, and do not use exercise balls.

Noise, schedule and running costs

Guinea pigs are vocal during the day. Their squeaks and purrs are part of the appeal, but they can be heard throughout a home. Hamsters are quieter, but they run wheels and dig at night, so keep the cage away from where you sleep if noise matters to you.

Guinea pigs cost more to keep. They eat more hay and fresh vegetables, need bigger enclosures, and live longer. Hamsters are cheaper to feed, but the enclosure, wheel and bedding still add up. For either pet, the setup often costs more than the animal.

Which should you choose?

Choose a guinea pig if you want a social pet that is active during the day, you can provide a large floor enclosure, and you can manage fresh food and hay every day for a commitment of 5 to 8 years.

Choose a hamster if you want a smaller, solitary pet, you can accept night-time activity, and you have a quiet place for the cage that will not disturb your sleep.

If a rabbit is also on your list, see rabbits vs guinea pigs as pets. For a more interactive rodent, compare rats vs hamsters as pets. For the wider picture, read small mammal pets: choosing the right rodent or rabbit.

The complete guide to choosing a small pet

Small Mammal Pets: Choosing the Right Rodent or Rabbit
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →